CONTROVERSIAL POLL!

[Naj]

It's not too surprising, ewka, we've done Survivor voteoff last year and Scotty got axed first. It's somewhere over in our Games forum. There may be some other threads too but right now I can't think of any. As far as popularity he isn't as well endeared as the other male detectives. See some of the threads over in Additional Cast. Mostly he's popular in regards to shippers of the Lilly/Scotty romantic leanings.

ewka said:

Almost half of the votes is for Scotty (up to now), yey! I can't believe it, if anyone asked me before, I'd never predict Valens to be the one to get killed by fans ;] No, I do not specially like him, but that fact seems to be weird to me.

[germanccfan]

I voted for Scotty, too. And I think it would be terrible if they would kill Stillman. I really think he is a good friend for Lilly!

[ewka]

It is 50% sharp Looks like we do not like him

[samanda]

I finally bit the bullet and voted for Scotty. We've practically had enough Scotty drama to last us for a few seasons so I don't mind him gone so much. I'll admit that I was pretty close to picking Jeffries. I've never really felt a connection to his character.